−Sm¡x Y¡L¡

Dcw¯’Z:

Rbve wePvicwZ Gg. Bbv‡qZzi iwng

Ges

Rbve wePvicwZ ‡gvt ‡gv¯ÍvwdRyi ingvb

−g±Sc¡l£ ¢l¢i ne j¡jm¡ ew-1735/2019 CeS¡j¡j¤m Cpm¡j Jl−g ¢Sp¡e     

........... Avmvgx-`iLv¯ KÍ vix|

ebvg

ivóª

................... c wÖ Zcÿ| Se¡h −j¡x BLl¡j E¢Ÿe, A¨vW‡fv‡KU

................... Avmvgx-`iLv¯ KÍ vixi c‡ÿ| ¢jp bymivZ Rvnvb, †WcywU A¨vUb©x †Rbv‡ij

................... c wÖ Zc‡ÿi c‡ÿ|

23 Bo¡t 1426 e½vã

     Av‡`‡ki ZvwiL t  07/07/2019 wLª÷vã

Bp¡j£-clM¡Ù¹L¡l£  Y¡L¡l  ¢h−no  c¡ul¡  SS,  Bc¡ma  ew-5  -H  ¢hQ¡l¡d£e ¢h−no  c¡ul¡  j¡jm¡  ew-360/2016;  k¡  d¡ej¢ä  b¡e¡l  j¡jm¡  ew-07(06)  2014 ®j¡a¡−hL ¢S|Bl| ew-163/2014 d¡l¡ 302/34 cä¢h¢d, 1860 q−a Eá a§ , -H ¢hNa 13/06/2019Cw a¡¢lM ¢h‘ ¢h−no ¢hQ¡lL LaѪL ®g±Sc¡l£ L¡k ¢Ñ h¢dl 540 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e Ae¤k¡u£  l¡øÊf−r  EfÙÛ¡¢fa  p¡r£  ¢f|X¡¢hÔE-1,5,6,7  Hhw 8  f e¤ xam−hl (recall)

B−hce e¡ j”¤l B−c−n pwr¥ì q−u ®g±Sc¡l£ L¡k ¢Ñ h¢dl 439 d¡l¡u Aœ clM¡Ù ¢¹ V c¡¢Mm œ²−j a¡ h¡¢am fË¡bÑe¡ L−l−Rez

clM¡Ù¹¢V öe¡e£ Qm¡L¡−m HL fkÑ¡−u clM¡Ù L¹ ¡l£l f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ clM¡Ù ¢¹ V EfÙÛ¡fe Ll−a BNËq£ ee j−jÑ ¢e−hce L−lez

¢h‘ BCeS£h£l Eš² hš²−hÉl ®fË¢r−a Aœ clM¡Ù j¹ −§ m Be£a Bp¡j£l fË¡b eÑ ¡ EfÙÛ¡¢fa qu¢e j−jÑ e¡j”¤l Ll¡ q−m¡z

fËpwNa  HM¡−e  E−õM  Ll¡  fË−u¡Se  ®k,  a¢L aÑ  B−cnpq  AeÉ¡eÉ  B−c−nl p¡¢VÑg¡CX L¢fpj§q, k¡ Aœ clM¡−Ù¹l p¡−b pwk¤š², q−a HV¡ c nª Éj¡e ®k, Y¡L¡l ¢h−no SS Bc¡ma ew-5-Hl ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡lL Se¡h ®j¡x BMa¡l¦‹¡j¡e a ¡y l e¡−j f −§ h A¢S aÑ "X|' (Xƒ−lV) ¢XNË£ hÉhq¡l Ll−Rez Cc¡¢ew ¢hQ¡¢lL L¡k œÑ ²j f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll−a ¢N−u fË¡unx

Bj¡−cl eS−l Bp−R ®k, ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−a ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡lLNe A−e−LCa ¡y −cl e¡−jl f§−hÑ A¢SÑa ¢XNË£ "Xƒ−lV' pw−r−f "X|' h¡ hÉ¡¢lø¡l E−õM h¡ hÉhq¡l Ll−Rez

"X|' (Xƒ−lV) N−hoe¡j§mL EµQal ¢nr¡l HL¢V ¢XNË£; Hhw "hÉ¡¢lø¡l' −fn¡Na

¢h−no HL¢V ®L¡pÑz p¤al¡w "X|' (Xƒ−lV) h¡ hÉ¡¢lø¡l LMeC ®L¡e hÉ¢š²l e¡−jl Awn q−a f¡−le¡z ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−al ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡lLhª−¾cl EµQal ¢nr¡ NËqe, ¢XNË£ m¡i ¢exp−¾c−q fËnwp¡l c¡h£ l¡−M Hhw H ¢hou¢V−L pLm jq−ml Evp¡q fËc¡e Hhw i¢hoÉ−a ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−al ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡lL−cl j−dÉ q−a A¢dL pwMÉL ¢hQ¡lL k¡−a EµQal ¢nr¡ J ¢XNË£ ASÑe Ll−a f¡−le ®p ¢ho−u plL¡l J p¤fË£j ®L¡−VÑl p¡¢hÑL f −ª ù¡−f oLa¡ fË−u¡Sez ¢L¿º, ¢hQ¡¢lL L¡kÑœ²j f¢lQ¡me¡l pju B−cn h¡ l¡−u ¢hQ¡l−Lle¡−jl f −§ hÑ A¢S aÑ ¢XNË£ e¡−jl Awn N−eÉ hÉhq¡l Ll¡ pj£Q£e eu; B−cn h¡ l¡−u öd¤ j¡œ ¢hQ¡l−Ll e¡j Hhw ¢a¢e ®L¡eÚ Bc¡m−al ¢hQ¡lL a¡ E−õM b¡L¡C pwNa Hhw h¡“e£uz

HM¡−e E−õM Ll¡ fË¡pw¢NL q−h ®k, h¡wm¡−cn p¤fË£j ®L¡−Vl Ñ Eiu ¢hi¡−N (Bf£m ¢hi¡N J q¡C−L¡VÑ ¢hi¡N) E−õM−k¡NÉpwMÉL ¢hQ¡lf¢al EµQ ¢nr¡l ¢XNË£ Hhw EµQ ®fn¡Na ®L¡pÑ pÇf−æl A¢i‘a¡ l−u−R, ¢L¿º j¡ee£u ¢hQ¡f¢aNZ l¡u h¡ B−c−n a ¡y −cl

e¡−jl f§−hÑ I pLm ¢XNË£ h¡ ®L¡−pÑl ¢hou E−õM L−le e¡ Hhw fËb¡ Ae k¤ ¡u£ p¤fË£j ®L¡−V lÑ LÉ¡−mä¡l, LS¢mø-pq c¡ç¢lL L¡−SJ a¡ LMeJ E−õM Ll¡ qu e¡z

Hja¡hÙÛ¡u, ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−al ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡lLN−Zl, k¡yl¡ EµQal ¢XNË£ ASÑe h¡

−fn¡Na EµQal ®L¡pÑ pÇf æ L−l−Re h¡ Ll−he, ¢hQ¡lL¡kÑœ²−j ¢h−noax l¡u, B−cn,

AXÑ¡ln£−V ay¡−cl e¡−jl Awn ¢q−p−h ¢XNË£ E−õM h¡“e£u/L¡jÉ euz HV¡ fËaÉn¡ Ll¡ eÉ¡kÉ

q−h ®k, pw¢nÔø ¢hQ¡lLNZ ü£u h¤¢Üjš¡ J fË‘¡ ¢c−u ¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡u ¢e−u e¡−jl Awn

¢q−p−h EµQal ¢XNË£l hÉhq¡l ®b−L ¢e−S−cl ¢hla l¡M−hez

fËpwNa B−l¡ E−õM Ll¡ ®k−a f¡−l ®k, B¿ S¹ ¡Ñ ¢aL f¡p−f¡VÑ-H LMeC e¡−jl

Awn ¢q−p−h ¢nr¡Na ®k¡NÉa¡/¢XNË£ h¡ Ae¡eÉ fch£ ®kje fË−L±nm£, X¡š²¡l, L ¢« oh£c, BCeS£h£ fËi«¢a hÉhq¡−ll p¤−k¡N ®eCz

 HM¡−e k¤¢š² E›¡¢fa q−a f¡−l ®k, fËn¡pe h¡ AeÉ LÉ¡X¡−ll Lj LÑ a ¡Ñ pq A−e−LC e¡−jl Awn ¢q−p−h e¡−jl f§−hÑ Hph ¢XNË£ E−õM L−l b¡−Le, a¡q−m ¢hQ¡l ¢hi¡−Nl LjÑLaÑ¡N−Zl EµQal ¢XNË£ E−õM J hÉhq¡−l h¡d¡ ®L¡b¡uz H fËpw−N Bj¡−cl p¤¢Q¢¿¹a A¢ija q−m¡ HC ®k, HLSe ¢hQ¡lL−L LMeC fËn¡pe h¡ AeÉ ®L¡e LÉ¡X¡−ll LjÑLaÑ¡−cl p¡−b a¥me¡ Ll¡ E¢Qa eu; H−a ¢hQ¡l¢hi¡N Hhw ¢hQ¡lLh −ª ¾cl üL£ua¡ J j¢qj¡C fËnÀ¢hÜ q−hz H fËp−‰ p¢Qh, AbÑ j¿»Z¡mu he¡j ®j¡x j¡pc¡l ®q −pe Nw j¡jm¡u Bf£m ¢hi¡−Nl A¢ija pj§q, kb¡x- “But as oil and water can not mix,

the judicial and civil administrative executive services are non-amalgamable”.

Hhw “Thus, it is clear that the member of the judicial service and the magistrates exercising judicial functions exercise judicial power of the state as distinct and separate

from executive power and other Cadre services of the state. --- ----------. It is to be borne in mind that judicial function is distinct from other functions as visualized in the constitution

itself” pÈlZ Ll¡ ®k−a f¡−l z p¤al¡w, fËn¡pe h¡ AeÉ LÉ¡X¡−ll ®L e Lj LÑ a ¡Ñ La LªÑ e¡−jl Awn ¢q−p−h EµQ ¢XNË£l hÉhq¡l h¡ ®fn¡Na ®L¡−pÑl E−õM ¢hQ¡l¢hi¡N£u Lj LÑ a ¡Ñ l

¢eLV Ae¤ple£u h¡ Ae¤Lle£u qJu¡-k¤¢š² pwNa ®L¡e L¡lZ q−a f¡−l e¡z

fËn¡pe J Ae¡eÉ LÉ¡X¡−ll pcpÉ−cl ¢eu¿ e» ¢eh ¡Ñ q£ ¢hi¡N Hhw pw¢n øÔ ¢e−u¡NL¡l£ LaѪf−rl q¡−az ay¡−cl nª´Mm¡pq p¡j¢NËL ¢hou ®cMi¡m Ll¡l hÉhÙ ¡Û J ¢iæz p¤a¡l¡w, fËn¡p−el h¡ AeÉ LÉ¡X¡−ll ®L¡e LjÑLa ¡Ñ l e¡−jl Awn ¢q−p−h EµQal ¢XNË£ E−õ−Ml ¢ho−u ¢hQ¡l¢hi¡−Nl −L¡el©f j¿¹hÉ q−h Ae¡L¡¢´Maz a−h, Bj¡−cl H Lb¡

hm−a ®L¡e ¢àd¡ −eC ®k, "Bf e ®nËùaÄ pð−å A¢a¢lš² fËaÉu hÉš² Ll¡l (superiority complex)' j¡e¢pLa¡ ®b−LC L¡−l¡ L¡−l¡'l j−dÉ A¢S aÑ ¢XNË£ e¡−jl Awn ¢q−p−h hÉhq¡−ll H fËhea¡z

Ef−l¡š² fkÑ−hrepq ®g±Sc¡l£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 439 d¡l¡l Aœ clM¡Ù ¢¹ V ¢eÖf¢š Ll¡ q−m¡z

fË−u¡Se£u AhN¢a J hÉhÙÛ¡ NËq−el SeÉ Aœ B−c−nl L¢f p¢n wøÔ Bc¡ma R¡s¡J

1z p¢Qh, BCe J ¢hQ¡l ¢hi ¡N, BCe ¢hQ¡l J pwpc ¢houL j¿»Z¡mu Hhw 2z ®l¢SØVÊ¡l

®Se¡−lm, h¡wm¡−cn p¤fË£j −L¡VÑ-Hl ¢eLV ®fËle Ll¡ ®q¡Lz

fËZh /H|¢h|J