h¡wm¡cn p¤fË£j ®L¡VÑ q¡CL¡YÑ~ ¢hi¡N
(¢p¢im ¢line¡m S¤¢lS¢XLn¡e)
X~f¢ÙÛa:
¢hQ¡lf¢a Se¡h nl£g E¢Ÿe Q¡Lm¡c¡l
Hhw
¢hQ¡lf¢a Se¡h nM ®j¡x S¡¢Ll ®q¡pe
cJu¡e¡£¢l¢ine ew 3473/2005
j¢Sh¤l lqj¡e -------ZicQvbx-cÖwZev x-clM¡ØaL¡l£z he¡j
e§l ®j¡q¡jÈc Nw ------jSql -A¡f£mL¡l£-AflfrNZ z Se¡h j¡qj¤c¤m Bmj,i¨Cyu¡ HÉ¡Xi¡LV,
----clM¡ØaL¡l£ frz Se¡h ®j¡x ýj¡u¤e h¡n¡l p‰
h¡h¤ A¢em Q¾cÐ ®che¡b, HÉ¡Xi¡LV àuz
-------Aflfrz öe¡e£ J l¡u fËc¡ex eiðl 28, 2012¢MËx
¢hQ¡lf¢a ®nM ®j¡x S¡¢Ll ®q¡pex
Aœ l¦m¢V Eáh qCu¡R j¡¢eLN”l ¢h‘ k¤NÈ Sm¡ SS, ¢àa£u Bc¡ma Hl ¢jp 3/2005 ew Bf£m fÐQ¡¢la 24/7/2005 ¢MËx a¡¢lMl l¡u J Bcn Hl ¢hl¦Ü, ®k l¡u J A¡cn p¡V¤¢lu¡l ¢h‘ ¢p¢eu¡l pqL¡l£ SS Bc¡mal ¢fËu¡jne ¢jp 18/2002 ew j¡jm¡u fÐQ¡¢la 20/11/2004¢MËx a¡¢lM l¡u J Bcn f¢lhaÑe f§hÑL A¡f£m¢V j”¤l qCu¡Rz
l¦m¢Vl ¢eÖf¢šl ü¡bÑ j¡jm¡l pw¢rç OVe¡ HC ®k, 1ew Aflfr jSql ¢qp¡h clM¡Øal ag¢nm h¢ZÑa pÇf¢š 1950 p¡ml l¡ÖVÊ£u A¢dNq ËZ fËS¡üaÄ A¡Ce Hl 96 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e ja ANœË²ul fËbÑe¡u p¡V¤¢lu¡l ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul pqL¡l£
1
SS Bc¡ma ¢fËu¡jne ¢h¢hd 18/2002 ew j¡jm¡ c¡ul Llez jSql Hl
clM¡Øal pw¢rç ¢hhlZ HC ®k, e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j Ef¾cÐ ®j¡qe p¡q¡l üaÄ cMm£u ¢Rmz a¡q¡l e¡j Hp,H, Hhw Bl, Hp ®lLÑX quz ¢a¢e üaÄ cMm f¢lQ¡me¡ L¢la b¡L¡hØq¡u l”e p¡q¡ J Eo¡ l” e p¡q¡L c¤C f¤œ l¡¢Mu¡ j¡l¡ k¡ez Eo¡
l”e p¡q¡ le¢Sv p¡q¡ J Evfm p¡q¡L c¤C f¤œ l¡¢Mu¡ j¡l¡ k¡ez je¡l”e p¡q¡
J le¢Sv L¤j¡l p¡q¡ Efk¤š² fe fËhª¢š j§m ¢hNa 21/01/2001 ¢MËx a¡¢lM 39
¢Xw i¥¢j jS ql hl¡hl ¢hœ²u L¢lu¡ cMm¡fÑZ Llez Evfm L¡¢¿¹ p¡q¡ Bx L¥Ÿ¤p J
®j¡x BLÚL¡p Bm£ 2 J 3 ew ¢hœ²a¡ alfR¡e£l ¢eLV 1234 ¢Xw i¨¢j HJu¡S
¢cu cMm AfÑZ Llez jSql e¡¢mn£ i¨¢ja M¢lc p§œ j¡¢mL cMmL¡l b¡¢Lu¡ AeÉ¡eÉ nl£Lcl p¢qa A¢hiš² Sj¡u ®i¡N cMm L¢laRez avfl 2-3 ew ¢hœ²a¡ alfR¡e£ A¢a ®N¡fe ¢hNa 24/12/2001¢MËx a¡¢lM 4088ew ®l¢S¢ØVL Ê«a p¡h Lhm¡ c¢mm j§m 1ew alfR¡e£l ¢eLV ¢hœ²u Lle Hhw Eq¡ p¡g Lhm¡ c¢mm e¡ L¢lu¡ jSqll ¢fËujne A¢dL¡l r¥æ Ll¡l SeÉ HJu¡S c¢mm ¢qp¡h pªSe L¢lu¡Rez jSql ¢hNa 29/5/2002¢MËx a¡¢lM EJ² c¢mml pC j¡ql£ eLm EW¡Cu¡ qØa¡¿¹ll ¢hou AhNa qez jSqlL nl£L ¢qp¡h ®L¡e ®e¡¢Vn fËc¡e Lle e¡Cz ®œ²a¡ algRe£ hl¡hl 2,3 ew ¢hœ²a¡ alfR¡e£
3
EJ² 124 ¢Xw i¥¢j 14/5/2002¢MËx a¡¢lM ®l¢S¢ÖVÊL«a p¡hLhm¡ c¢mm j ¤m
qØa¡¿¹l L¢lu¡Rez e¡¢mn£ S¢j Bc± HJu¡S j¤m qØq¡¿¹l qu e¡Cz e¡¢mn£ c¢mm¢V p¡h ¢hœ²u c¢mmz ®œ²a¡ alfR¡e£ e¡¢mn£ S¢ja BN¿¹L ¢hd¡u jSql e¡¢mn£ ®S¡a nl£L fÐS¡ ¢qp¡h ANËœ²u f¡Ju¡l A¢dL¡l£z
1ew ®œ²a¡ alfR¡e£ HL¢V ¢m¢Ma Bf¢š c¡¢Mm Llez HC alfR¡e£ c¡h£
Lle ®k, e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j Ef¾cÐ p¡q¡, L¢Rj¤¢Ÿe pq BlJ AeL üaÄh¡e cMmL¡l ¢Rmez ¢hNa 25/2/61 ¢MËx a¡¢lM L¢Rj¤¢Ÿe a¡q¡l Awnl 38 ¢Xw Hl L¡a
33 ¢Xw i¥¢j 1ew ®œ²a¡ alfR¡e£l ¢fa¡ e¤l ®j¡q¡jÈcl ¢eLV e¡¢mn£ 1090 c¡Nl i¥¢jl ¢hœ²u Llez ¢a¢e cMmL¡l b¡L¡hØq¡u HC alfR¡e£ pq Q¡l f¤œ J Q¡l
LeÉ¡ l¡¢Mu¡ j¡l¡ k¡ez ®pC ¢qp¡h alfR¡e£ ®~f¢œL p§œ nl£L z Afl nl£Lcl
3
jdÉ Eo¡l ØH£L frLl¡ qu e¡Cz Evfm L¡¢¿¹ p¡q¡ a¡q¡l Awnl 124 ¢Xw
i¨¢j Na 21/3/2000¢MËx a¡¢lM 2 J 3 ew ¢hœ²a¡ Bx L¥Ÿp J Bî¡p Bm£l ¢eLV qØa¡¿¹l Lle Hhw ®i¡N cMml p¤¢hd¡bÑ HC alfR¡e£ J Bx L¥Ÿ¤p ¢hNa 24/12/2001 ¢MËx a¡¢lM ®l¢S¢øÊL«a c¢mm j§m e¡¢mn£ S¡¢jl HJu¡S hcm j§m
3
cMm h¤¢Tu¡ ®ee Hhw 1070 c¡Nl 124 ¢Xw i¨¢j Bx L¥Ÿ¤p NwL cMm h¤¢Tu¡
®cez e¡¢mn£ i¨¢ja 1 ew alfR¡e£ HJu¡S c¢mm j§m cMm h¤¢Tu¡ ¢eu¡ 5 ¢Xw
i¨¢ja j¡¢V L¡¢Vu¡ ¢ae¢V Ol Eš¡me Lle, H ¢V ¢Vel ®c¡Q¡m¡ Ol Hhw HL¢V
f¡V M¢sl ®hs¡l ¢Vel ®c¡Q¡m¡ Ol, HL¢V R¡fs¡ Olz h¡s£a j§mÉh¡e N¡R f¡m¡ l¢qu¡Rz Cq¡a alfR¡e£l fË¡u ®cs mr V¡L¡ MlQ quz e¡¢mn£ S¢j HJu¡S
j§m qÙ¹¡¿¹ll fl qCa pLml ‘¡ap¡l cMm f¢lQ¡me¡ L¢lu¡ B¢paRez ®N¡fe ®L¡e ¢hœ²u qu e¡C Hhw ®L¡e V¡L¡ fup¡ ®mece qu e¡Cz e¡¢mn£ c¢mm fËL«afr HJu¡S hcm c¢mm ¢hd¡u jSql 1950 p¡ml l¡øÌ£u A¢dNËqZ J fËS¡üaÄ BCel 96 d¡l¡l 10(M) Ef-d¡l¡ ¢hd¡e ja ANËœ²u f¡Ju¡l A¢dL¡l£
euz
Aaxfl ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡¢V ¢eÖf¢šl ¢e¢jš 5¢V Cp¤É NWe Llez jSql fr a¡q¡l j¡jm¡ fËj¡el SeÉ 3 Se ®j±¢ML p¡r£ Hhw ¢LR¤ c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ EfÙÛ¡fe Lle k¡q¡ fËcnÑe£ ÔÔ1 J 2ÕÕ ¢qp¡h ¢Q¢q²a quz AeÉ
¢cL 1ew algR¡e£ a¡qy¡l j¡jm¡ fjË¡Zl SeÉ 2 Se ®j±¢ML p¡r£ pq ®k c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ EfØq¡fe Lle, a¡q¡ fËcnÑe£-ÔL qCa MÕ fkÑ¿¹ ¢Q¢q²a quz Eiu frl p¡rÉ¢c, fcnÑË e£ pj§q ¢hQ¡l ¢hnÔoZ, ¢h‘ A¡CeS£h£cl k¢š²aLÑ nËhZ J j§mÉuZ f§hÑL ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma c¡¢MmL«a ANœË²ul j¡jm¡¢V 1ew algR¡e£l
¢hl¦Ü ®c¡alg¡ p§œ Hhw AeÉ¡eÉcl ¢hl²Ü HLalg¡ p§œ ¢he¡ MlQ¡u M¡¢lS Llez
EJ² M¡¢lSl l¡u J Bcnl ¢hl²Ü jSql Bf£mL¡l£ ¢qp¡h j¡¢eLN”
¢h‘ ®Sm¡ SS Bc¡ma ¢jp 03/2005 ew A¡f£m c¡ul Llez EJ² ¢jp Bf£m¢V öe¡e£l SeÉ j¡¢eLN”l ¢h‘ k¤NÈ ®Sm¡ SS, ¢àa£u Bc¡ma hcm£ quz
¢h‘ k¤NÈ ®Sm¡ SS Eiu frl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£cl k¤¢š² aLÑ nËhZ, e¢ba pwl¢ra p¡r¡¢c, fËcnÑe£ pj§q Hhw AeÉ¡eÉ L¡NSfœ ¢hQ¡l ¢hnÔoZ f§hÑL Bf£m¢V fË¢aࢾcÄ 1ew alfR¡e£-fТah¡c£l ¢hl¦Ü ®c¡alg¡ p§œ Hhw AeÉ¡eÉ fТah¡c£cl ¢hl¦Ü HL alg¡ p§œ ¢he¡ MlQ¡u j”¤l Lle Hhw ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡mal l¡u J Bcn lc J l¢qa Llez EJ² l¡u J Bcnl ¢hl¦Ü pwr¥Ü qCu¡ 1ew algR¡e£-fË¢ah¡c£ clM¡ØaL¡l£ ¢qp¡h ®cJu¡e£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 115(1) d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e ja ¢l¢inel clM¡Øa c¡¢Mm L¢lm Aœ l¦ml Eáh quz
l¦m¢V öe¡e£ L¡m 1ew alfR¡e£-fТah¡c£-clM¡ØaL¡l£fr l ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h j¡qÚj¤c¤m Bmj i¨Cyu¡ ¢ehce Lle ®k, ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma j§max HLV¡ HJu¡S hcm c¢mm ®L p¡ghm¡ c¢mm ¢qp¡h j§mÉ¡ue L¢lu¡ acf¢lfË¢ra Aœ ANËœ²u j¡jm¡¢V j”¤l f§hÑL ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma Hl l¡u J
Bcn lc J l¢qa L¢lu¡Re ¢L¿ º¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma ®k A¢ijal ¢i¢ša
¢fËu¡jne j¡jm¡¢V M¡¢lS L¢lu¡¢Rme k¡q¡ kb¡Ñb ¢Rmz¢a¢e Bl¡ ¢ehce Lle
®k, ¢h¢eju ab¡ HJu¡S hcm c¢mml ¢hl²Ü L¡e ¢fËujne j¡jm¡ Qm e¡, k¡q¡
1950 p¡ml l¡øÌ£u A¢dNËqZ J fËS¡paÄ BCel 96 d¡l¡l (10) Hl (M) Ef -
d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ h¡¢la ¢L¿¹ ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma HC pLm ¢cL ¢hhQe¡ e¡ L¢lu¡
ïj f¢aa qCu¡ a¢LÑa l¡u fËc¡e L¢lu¡Re k¡q¡ eÉ¡u ¢hQ¡ll ü¡bÑ lc J l¢qa ®k¡NÉ ¢hd¡u l¦m¢V Q§s¡¿¹ qJu¡l ¢ehce Llez
AeÉ¢cL,jSql -A¡f£mL¡l£-1ew Aflfr ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h ®j¡x
ýj¡Ee h¡n¡l pw‰ h¡h¤ A¢em Q¾cÐ ®che¡b l¦ml ¢hl¡¢da¡ L¢lu¡ ¢ehce Lle
®k, ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma ¢hØa¡¢la Bm¡Qe¡l f¢lfТra BCel p¤ hÉ¡MÉ¡ pq fËaÉL¢V ¢hQ¡kÑ ¢hou f´¤M¡e¤f¤´M ¢hQ¡l ¢hnÔoZ f§hÑL l¡u¢V fËc¡e L¢lu¡Re ®kM¡e qØarf Ll¡l ®L¡e AhL¡n BCea e¡C ¢hd¡u l¦m¢V M¡¢lS qChz ¢a¢e
Bl¡ ¢ehce Lle ®k, k¢cJ L¢ba c¢mm¢V HJu¡S hcm ¢qp¡h ®cM¡ k¡u ¢L¿¹ flha£Ña 1ew algR¡e£-clM¡ØaL¡l£ 15/5/2002¢MËx a¡¢lM ag¢nml e¡¢mn£
pÇf¢š ®gla Lhm¡ ¢eu¡Re, k¡q¡ fËL¡l¡¿¹l ¢hœ²u c¢mm ¢qp¡h fË¢aù¡ f¡uz H®rœ ¢a¢e Bl¡ ¢ehce Lle ®k, jSql -Afl frL ANËœ²u qCa h¢’a
Ll¡l L¥j¡eo p¤L±nm HJu¡S hcm c¢mml A¿¹l¡m p¡h Lhm¡ c¢mm pÇfæ
qCu¡R ¢hd¡u jSql -Bf£mL¡l£ 1ew Aflfr l ANËœ²ul c¡h£ Ll¡l kbÖV
k¤¢š² k¤š² L¡lZ ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rm ¢hd¡u ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma ANËœ²u j¡jm¡¢V j”¤l
L¢lu¡Rez
Eiu frl ¢hS· BCeS£h£l hJ²hÉ A¡jl¡ AaÉ¡¿¹ dkÑÉpqL¡l£ nËhZ
L¢lm¡jz ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma a¡q¡l l¡u ¢hØa¡¢la A¡m¡Qe¡ L¢lu¡Re, k¢cJ
Eiu frl jdÉ HLV¡ ¢houC ¢ha¢LÑa a¡q¡ qCm a¢LÑa ANËœ²u c¢mm¢V HJu¡S hcm c¢mm e¡¢L p¡g Lhm¡ c¢mm? Bj¡cl p¡je a¡q¡C HLj¡œ ¢hQ¡kÑ ¢houz e¢bcªø ®cM¡ k¡uL¢ba c¢mm¢V k¡q¡ 14/12/2001¢MËx a¡¢lM pÇf¡¢ca J ®l¢S¢ÖVÊ L«a Hhw k¡q¡l H²¢jL e¡ð¡l 4088,a¡q¡ 1ew Aflfr -jSql kje ¢ejÀ
¢hQ¡¢lL A¡c¡ma c¡¢Mm L¢lu¡R Hhw k¡q¡ ÔfËcnÑe£-2Õ ¢qp¡h ¢Q¢q²a qCu¡R,
®aj¢e clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ 1ew algR¡e£fr J a¡q¡ ¢ejÀ A¡c¡ma c¡¢Mm L¢lu¡Re, k¡q¡
ÔfËcnÑe£-MÕ ¢qp¡h ¢Q¢q²a qCu¡R, ah jSql fr c¡ ¢Mm L«a c¢mm¢V p¡¢VÑg¡CX L¢f, AeÉ ¢cL 1ew algR¡e£fr c¡¢Mm L«a c¢mm¢V j§m L¢f HC k¡q¡ f¡bÑLÉz
L¢ba fËcnÑe£¢V fl£r¡ L¢lm ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, c¢mml fËbj fªÖW¡u Hhw fËbj m¡CeC ÔÔHJu¡S h¡ hcm e¡j¡ c¢mmÕÕ ¢nl¡e¡j EõM pq ®kM¡e p¤ÖfÖV i¡h
3
EõM l¢qu¡R ""fËbj fr HJu¡S fË¡ç i¥¢jl f¢lj¡Z 124 nx ®j±S¡ d§mÉ¡ jdÉ
3
j§mÉ 6,000/- V¡L¡z ¢àa£u fr HJu¡S fË¡ç i¨¢j 124 nx ®j±S¡ d§mÉ¡ jdÉ j§mÉ
6000/- V¡L¡ b¡e¡ J CE¢eue p¡V¤¢lu¡Ó Hhw pjØa c¢mml NiÑ HJu¡S e¡j¡ c¢mm ¢qp¡h EõM l¢qu¡R k¡q¡l ®L¡b¡J p¡h-Lhm¡ c¢mml ¢h¾c¤-¢hpN ÑEõM e¡Cz
e¢b cªø ®cM¡ k¡u jSql 1ew Aflfr ¢f, X¡¢hÔE-1 ¢qp¡h Sh¡eh¢¾ca
hme ÔÔ e¡¢mn£ c¢mml eLm EW¡Cz HJu¡S c¢mm LlR ®c¢MÕÕz ®Sl¡u hme, ÔÔe¡¢mn£ c¢mm HJu¡S LlR ¢fÐujne ¢hm¡fl SeÉ LlRÕÕz 2ew ¢f, X¡¢hÔE ®Sl¡u ü£L¡l Lle ®k ÔÔbvwjkx `wjj GIqvR `wjjÕÕ| 3bs wc, WvweD Revbew› ‡Z e‡jb ÔÔAvwg gRni ZicQvb£ I bvwjkx Rwg wPwb| gwRei iLv¯—-
Kvix 1bs ZicQvbx mvd Kejv K‡i 6,000/-g~‡j¨ wbqv‡Q GIqvR wjj † LvqÕÕ|
®kqa¥ Efl¡š² p¡r£cl p¡rÉ ja J ü£L«a ®k, a¢LÑa fËcnÑe£ ab¡ ANËœ²u pÇf¢LÑa pÇf¢šl c¢mm¢V HJu¡S hcm c¢mm, ®pqa¥ Eš² c¢mm¢V 1950
p¡ml l¡øÌ£u A¢dNËqZ J fËS¡üaÄ BCel 96 d¡l¡ (10) (M) Ef-d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ ANËœ²u Hl BJa¡j¤š², k¡q¡ ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma ¢hhQe¡ f§hÑL j§mÉ¡ue L¢la
hÉbÑa¡u fkÑ¡h¢pa qCu¡ a¢LÑa l¡u fËc¡e L¢lu¡Re h¢mu¡ Bj¡cl A¢ija, k¢cJ ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma a¡q¡l l¡u AeÉ¡eÉ ¢hou p¤¢hØa¡l Bm¡Qe¡ L¢lu¡Rez ®kqa¥ a¢LÑa c¢mm¢V ANËœ²®ul BJa¡u fs ¢Le¡ a¡q¡C fËd¡e
¢hhQÉ ¢hou a¡C Bjl¡ AeÉ¡eÉ ¢hou Bm¡Qe¡ L¢la ¢hla l¢qm¡jz p¡¢hÑL ¢hhQe¡u Bj¡cl ¢eLV fË¢auj¡e ®k jSql -A¡f£mL¡l£- 1ew Aflfr ANËœ²ul
c¡h£a ®k c¢mm¢V QÉ¡m” L¢lu¡ j¡jm¡ c¡ul L¢lu¡Re a¡q¡ kqa¥ HL¢V
HJu¡S hcm c¢mm ¢qp¡h p¤Öføi¡h fТauj¡e ®pqa¥ 1950 p¡ml l¡øÌ£u A¢dNÊqZ J fÐS¡üaÅ A¡Cel 96 d¡l¡l 10(M) Ef-d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e Ae¤k¡u£ jSql- A¡f£mL¡l£ -1ew Aflfrl ANËœ²u j¡jm¡¢V A¡Cea AQmz
Hja¡hÙÛ¡u, Efl¡J² Bm¡Qe¡l ¢i¢ša ¢ejÀ Bf£m Bc¡mal l¡u qØqrf Ll¡l ja kbÖV k¤¢J²p‰a L¡lZ ¢e¢qa b¡L¡u Hhw clM¡Ù¹L¡l£fr l¦m¢V Q§s¡¿¹ qJu¡l A¡Cep‰a ®qa¥h¡c ¢hcÉj¡e b¡L¡u l¦m¢V Q¨s¡¿¹ Ll¡ qCm Hhw ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡mal
¢jp 3/2003 ew A¡f£m fÐQ¡¢la 24/7/2005 ¢MËx a¡¢lMl l¡u J Bcn lc J l¢qa Ll¡ qCm Hhw ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡mal ¢fÐujne ¢jp 8/2002ew j¡jm¡u fÐQ¡¢la 20/11/2004 ¢MËx a¡¢lMl l¡u J Bcn hq¡m l¡M¡ qCmz
l¡ul L¢f pq ¢ejÀ Bc¡mal e¢b A¢apaÄl ®gla fËc¡e Ll¡ qELz
¢hQ¡lf¢a nl£g E¢Ÿe Q¡Lm¡c¡lx
B¢j HLja
g¢lc M¡e/H,¢h,J