h¡wm¡­cn p¤fË£j ®L¡VÑ                      q¡C­L¡YÑ~ ¢hi¡N

(¢p¢im wiwfkbvj S¤¢lS¢XLÚn¡e)

X~f¢ÙÛax

   ¢hQ¡lf¢a Se¡h nl£g E¢Ÿe Q¡Lm¡c¡l

   Hhw

   ¢hQ¡lf¢a Se¡h ­nM ®j¡x S¡¢Ll ®q¡­pe

­cJu¡e£¢l¢ine ew 4533/2007

                               ­N±l¡‰ q¡Sl¡ Nw

                                    ---------algR¡e£-®lØfe­X¾V-clM¡Ù¹L¡l£z

-he¡j-

                                j¤L¥¾c Ll Ms

                ----jS ql- Bf£mL¡l£-Afl frNZz      Se¡h pc¡e¾c l¡e¡, HÉ¡X­i¡­LV,

                                    ----clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ f­rz                                   Se¡h ®N±aj L¥j¡l l¡u, HÉ¡X­i¡­LV,

                                                                  ------1-3 ew Afl f­rz

öe¡e£ J l¡u fËc¡ex ¢X­pðl 13, 2012z

¢hQ¡lf¢a ®nM ®j¡x S¡¢Ll ®q¡­pex

Aœ l¦m¢V Eáh qCu¡­R ­N¡f¡mN®”l ¢h‘  fËbj k¤NÈ ®Sm¡ SS Bc¡m­al ¢jp 9/2006 ew Bf£­m fËQ¡¢la 20/06/2007¢MËx a¡¢l­Ml l¡u J B­c­nl ¢hl¦­Ü, ®k l¡u J B­cn j¤­m ®N¡f¡mN­”l ­L¡V¡m£f¡s¡l ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul pqL¡l£ SS Bc¡m­al ¢jp 13/1998 ew j¡jm¡u 20/04/2006 ¢MËx a¡¢l­Ml fËQ¡¢la l¡u J B­cn lc J l¢qa j­jÑ Ef­l¡š² ¢jp Bf£m¢V j”¤l

qCu¡­Rz

l¦m¢V ¢eØf¢šl ü¡­bÑ pw¢rç OVe¡ HC ®k, AflfrNZ jSql ¢qp¡­h     e¡¢mn£ ag¢p­ml pÇf¢š ANËœ²­ul fË¡bÑe¡u 1950 p¡­ml l¡ØVÊ£u A¢dNËqZ J fË¡S¡üaÄ BC­el 96 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e Ae¤k¡u£ ®N¡f¡mN” ­Sm¡l ®L¡V¡m£f¡s¡l

¢h‘ ¢p¢eul pqL¡l£ SS Bc¡m­a ¢jp 13/98 ew j¡jm¡ c¡­ul L­lez

jSql f­rl clM¡­Øal pw¢rç ¢hhlZ HC ®k, e¡¢mn£ Hp,H,29 M¢au¡­e jSq­ll ¢fa¡jq£ jq¡l¡e£l e¡j ®lLXÑ i¥š² B­Rz jq¡l¡e£ Hp,H, Sl£­fl fl ­cqaÉ¡N L¢l­m Q¡l f¤œ Ln¥£m¡m, Sm¡dl Jl­g SW¡dl, q£l¡ m¡m, pc¡e¾c Ll Ju¡¢ln b¡­Lez HR¡s¡ e¡¢mn£ 20,24,77 M¢au¡­e Eš² Q¡l

ï¡a¡l e¡j ®lLXÑ quz Aaxfl L¥n£m¡m J Smdl f¤œ LeÉ¡ ¢hq­e ®cqaÉ¡N L¢l­m c¤C i¡C q£l¡m¡m J pc¡e¾c Ju¡¢ln b¡­Lez q£l¡m¡m ®cqaÉ¡N L¢l­m HL f§œ h¡cm Ll, HL Ù»£ n¡¢¿¹ma¡ Ju¡¢ln b¡­Le z Aaxfl pc¡e¾c Ll ­cq

aÉ¡N L¢l­m c¤C f¤œ jSqlàu Ju¡¢ln b¡­Lez flhaÑ£­a 2ew jSql ­cqaÉ¡N a¡q¡l c¤C ®j­u Aœ j¡jm¡u fri ¤J¥ ² quz

HCi¡­h jSqlfr ­S¡­a pq nl£Lz jSqlN­Zl nl£L q£l¡m¡m L­ll

f¤œ h¡cm Ll J Ù»£ n¡¢¿¹ma¡ Ll jSql­ cl nl£¢L ®e¡¢Vn e¡ ¢cu¡ ®N¡f­e e¡¢mn£ i¨¢jpq Afl 07 naL ¢j­m 1.19 HLl i§¢j 22-7-97 ¢MËx a¡¢l­M 2493 ew p¡h Lhm¡ c¢mm j§­m 1-3 ew algR¡e£l ¢eLV ¢hœ²u L­lez 1-3

ew algR¡e£ ®S¡­a nl£L eu BN¿¹Lz e¡¢mn£ c¢m­m 6 ¢V ag¢pm E­õM B­Rz Eš² Lhm¡l 1ew af¢p­m E­õ¢Ma Hp,H, 65 M¢au¡­el ¢h¢œ²a 07

naL S¢j h¡hc ANËœ²­ul c¡h£ h¢qi¨Ña l¡M¡ qCu¡­Rz jSqlNZ e¡¢mn£ Lhm¡l 2-6 ew ag¢p­m ¢h¢œ²a ®j¡V 1.12 HLl i¨¢j ANËœ²­ul fË¡bÑe¡ L­lez

Afl ¢c­L 1-3 ew algR¡e£ Bf¢š c¡¢Mm L¢lu¡ j¡jm¡u fТaࢾàa¡ L­le, a¡q¡­cl hÉš²hÉ qCm, Aœ j¡jm¡ haÑj¡e BL¡­l AQm, a¡j¡¢c,

fr­ c¡o, J­ui¡l, HÉ¡L¥C­S¾p e£¢a­a h¡¢laz fËL«a hªš¡¿¹¹ HC ®k,h¡cm Ll

J n¡¢e¿¹ma¡ Ll e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j­a üaÄh¡e b¡L¡ L¡­m ¢hœ²­ul fЭu¡Se qC­m

jSql ®cl œ²u L¢l­a Ae¤­l¡d L­lez a¡q¡l¡ œ²u L¢l­a Af¡lNa¡ fËL¡n L¢l­m e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j HC algR¡e£­cl ¢eLV ¢h¢œ² L¢lu¡ ¢c­he j­jÑ ¢h­œ²a¡ n¡¢¿¹ma¡ J h¡cm Ll­L BnÄ¡p ®cez Aaxfl jSql NZ a¡q­cl h¡s£­a X¡¢Lu¡

HC algR¡e£­cl­L e¡¢mn£ S¢j M¢lc L¢l­a Ae¤­l¡d L­lez jSql ­cl jdÉÙ¹a¡u J ü¢œ²u i¨¢jL¡u HC algR¡e£fr e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j M¢lc L¢l­a l¡S£

qez jSql­cl Ef¢ÙÛ¢a J a¡q¡­cl Ae¤j¢aœ²­j öhlZ jäm,d£­l¾cÐ e¡b jäm, n¡¢¿¹ l”e f¡­V¡u¡l£, ®~n­m¾cÐ e¡b ¢hnÄ¡­pl ­j¡L¡­hm¡ HC algR¡e£NZ 22.07.1997 ¢MËx a¡¢lM 2493 ew Lhm¡ c¢mm j§­m e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j M¢lc L¢lu¡

cMm fË¡ç qez 27.07.1997 ¢MÊx a¡¢l®M 1ew algR¡e£ e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j­a HLM¡e¡ ®c¡Q¡m¡ ¢V­el Ol ¢ejÑ¡Z L­lez Eš² Ol ¢ejÑ¡Z L¢l­a 5,500/ - V¡L¡ MlQ qCu¡­Rz hph¡­pl Ef­k¡N£ Ll¡l SeÉ ag¢pm h¡s£l c¡­N 2,200/- V¡L¡l

j¡¢V E­š¡me L¢lu¡­Rez e¡¢mn£ h¡s£l c¡­N 1ew algR¡e£ f¢lh¡l f¢lSe

¢eu¡ hph¡p L¢l­a­Rez 1ew algR¡e£ e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j­a ®q¡Q¡V¡¢eu¡ HL¢V L¤u¡

®~a¢l L¢lu¡­Rez Eq¡­a algR¡e£l 4,500/- V¡L¡ MlQ qCu¡­Rz ag¢p­ml

AeÉ HL¢V c¡­Nl S¢j­a ¢h­œ²a¡ algR¡e£ HL¢V m£S °au¡l L¢lu¡¢R­mez HC algR¡e£NZ ¢h­œ²a¡­cl ¯al£ ¢m­S 2,000/-V¡L¡u ¢h¢iæ fÐS¡¢al j¡­Rl

®f¡e¡ R¡¢su¡­Rez HC algR¡e£ fr ag¢pm h¢ZÑa i¨¢jl j­dÉ HLV¤ e£Q¤

S¢j­a LQ¤ J d¡­el Q¡l¡ Evf¡ce L¢l­a­Rz Eq¡­a algR¡e£ fr 5000/- V¡L¡ MlQ L¢lu¡­Rez X~š² S¢j­a d¡­el Q¡l¡ J LQ¥l Q¡l¡ m¡N¡C­a 1500/-

V¡L¡ MlQ qCu¡­Rz alg R¡e£ fr Eš² L¡S…¢m ¢X­pðl j¡­pl j­dÉ pÇfæ L¢lu¡­Rez algR¡e£fr e¡¢mn£ i§¢j­a ®j¡V 20,700/-V¡L¡ Eæue j§mL L¡­S MlQ L¢lu¡­Rez jSql fr Bw¢nL ANËœ²u c¡h£ L­le a¡q¡ ®h-BCe£z e¡¢mn£ i¨¢jl j§mÉ hª¢Ü f¡Ju¡u jSqlfr ¢jbÉ¡ hZÑe¡u Aœ j¡jm¡ Be¡ue L¢lu¡­Rez jS¡ql­cl j¡jm¡ M¢l­Sl fË¡bÑe¡ L­lez

Aaxfl ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma j¡jm¡¢V ¢eÖf¢šl SeÉ 7¢V ¢hQ¡kÑ ¢hou NWe L­lez jS qlfr a¡q¡­cl j¡jm¡ fËj¡­Zl SeÉ 4Se ®j±¢ML p¡r£ Hhw ¢LR¤ c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ Bc¡m­a Ef¢ÙÛa L­le,c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ…¢m fËcnÑe£ 1 ¢p¢lS J 2 ¢qp¡­h ¢Q¢q²a quz AeÉ¢c­L algR¡e£fr a¡q¡­cl j¡jm¡ fËj¡­Zl

SeÉ 5 Se ®j±¢ML p¡r£ Bc¡m­a EfÙÛ¡fe L­lez ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma Eiu f­rl ®j±¢ML Hhw c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ¡¢c fkÑ¡­m¡Qe¡, Eiu f­rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£­cl k¤¢š²aL ÑnËhZ Hhw j§mÉ¡ue f§hÑL j§max j¡jm¡¢V J­ui¡l Hhw HÉ¡L¤C­S¾p ­c¡­o h¡¢lapq jSql f ­r l Bw¢nL ANËœ²u Hl c¡h£ ANË¡qÉj­jÑ j¡jm¡¢V jSqlf­r l fË¢aL¨­m e¡-j”¤­ll B­cn fËc¡e L­lez

Aaxfl EJ² 20/4/2006¢MËx a¡¢l­Ml ANËœ²u j¡jm¡ e¡-j”¤­ll l¡u J        B­c­nl ¢hl¦­Ü jSqlNZ Bf£mL¡l£ ¢qp¡­h ¢ ‘ ®Sm¡ SS, ®N¡f¡mN”,     A¡c¡m­a ¢jp 9/2006ew Bf£m c¡­ul L­le, k¡q¡ öe¡e£l ¢e¢j­š ¢h‘ k¤NÈ ®Sm¡ SS, 1j Bc¡m­a hcm£ quz ¢h‘ k¤NÈ ®Sm¡ SS 1j A¡c¡ma ¢ejÀ A¡c¡m­al l¡u Hhw e¢b­a pwl¢ra AeÉ¡eÉ c¢mmfœ Hhw Eiuf­rl ¢h‘

BCeS£h£­cl hJ²hÉ nËhZ J j§mÉ¡ue f§hÑL A¢ija NËqZ L­le ®k, ¢ejÀ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma j¡jm¡l J­ui¡l Hhw H¡¡L¥C­S¾p e£¢a­a h¡¢lapq Bw¢nL ANœË²u AQm j­jÑ ®k l¡u J B­cn fËc¡e L¢lu¡­Re a¡q¡ p¢WL qu e¡C ¢hd¡u ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡m­al l¡u J B­cn lc J l¢qa qJu¡l ®k¡NÉ Hhw Bf£mL¡l£ jSqlNZf­r ANËœ²u j”¤l L­lez Aaxfl ¢h‘ k¤NÈ ®Sm¡ SS fËbj Bc¡m­al 20/4/2006 ¢MËx a¡¢­lM Eš² l¡u J B­c­nl ¢hl¦­Ü pwr¥ì qCu¡ algR¡e£-®lØfe­X¾Vfr- clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ ¢qp¡­h Aœ ¢l¢ine c¡­ul L¢l­m Aœ l¦­ml Eáh quz

l¦m¢V öe¡e£L¡­m clM¡Ù¹L¡l£f­r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h¡h ¤pc¡e¾c l¡e¡

l¦­ml üf­r ¢e­hce L­le ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ A¡f£m A¡c¡ma J­ui¡l Hhw HÉ¡LC¥­S¾p e£¢a­a h¡¢la eu j­jÑ ®k A¢ija hÉJ² L¢lu¡­Re a¡q¡ lrZ£u e­qz algR¡e£-­lØfe­X¾V-clM¡Ù¹L¡l£fr ®kje a¡q¡­cl ¢m¢Ma Bf¢š­a E­õM L¢lu¡­Re ®k, jS ql-Bf£mL¡l£-AflfrNZ e¡¢mn£ ag¢p­ml pÇf¢š M¢lc L¢l­a Af¡lNa¡ fËL¡n L¢lu¡¢R­me, ®aj¢e p¡r£­cl à¡l¡J ¢h‘ Bc¡m­a fËj¡Z L¢l­a prj qCu¡­Re Hhw a¡q¡ ¢hQ¡l ¢h­nÔoZ J j§mÉ¡ue f§hÑL ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma ®k A¢ij­al ¢i¢š­a

l¡u fËc¡e L¢lu¡­Re a¡q¡ kb¡bÑ Hhw BCe¡e¤Nz ¢a¢ M¤h ®S¡l¡mi¡­h ¢e­hce L­le ®k, jSql Bf£mL¡l£-Aflf­rl j¡j¡m¡¢V J­ui¡l Hhw HÉ¡L¥C­S¾p e£¢a­a p¤Øføi¡­h h¡¢la ®Lee¡ a¡q¡­cl jdÉÙÛa¡C ¢h­œ²a¡NZ alfR¡e£-­lØf­ä¾V-clM¡Ù¹L¡l£­cl ¢eLV e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j ¢h¢œ²

L¢lu¡ i¡l­a Q¢mu¡ k¡ez H­r­œ ¢a¢e HLm¡Q¥l lqj¡e Nw he¡j n¢gEõ¡q

Nw 42 ¢X,Hm,Bl (H¢X) 189  ®kM¡­e p­hÑ¡µQ A¡c¡m­a ¢pÜ¡¿¹ qu ®k,”Waiver – It is the abandonment of a right, and

is either express or implied –it may be implied from conduct which is inconsistent with the continuance

of the right.

Acquiecence in its proper legal sence acquiecence implies that a person abstains from interfering while a violation of his legal right is in progress – it operates by way of estoppel”

Hhw ®l¡­Lu¡ ®hNj he¡j ®j¡x Bh¤ S¡­ql Nw 5 ¢h,Hm,¢p (H¢X) 97, ®kM¡­e ¢pÜ¡¿¹ qu ®k, ÔÔThe judgment of the lower appellate

Court being based on non-consideration of the material evidence of the DWs 1-3 who categorically testified that

the pre-emptor, cousin sister of pre-emptee living in

the same village,knew about the sale from the vey beginning assuring the pre-emptor to help in purchasing the land and she having refused to purchase the case land the same was sold to the pe- emptee and such non-consideration of the vital mateial evidence affected the meit of the case when the revisional court correctly found that the deposition of

the PWs 1 to 3 had not at all been discussed and

considered as has been done by the trial court.ÕÕ

®j¡LŸj¡à­u Nªq£a ¢pÜ¡¿¹àu Aœ ®j¡LŸj¡u e¢Sl ¢qp¡­h E­õM L­lez ¢h‘

A¡CeS£h£ A¡­l¡ ¢e­hce L­le ®k, ®k j§­mÉ NË¡j A’­m S¢j ¢h¢œ² qu a¡q¡l ®Q­u Lj j§mÉ ab¡ plL¡l La«ÑL ¢eh¡¢la j§mÉ ®cM¡Cu¡ S¢j ®l¢S¢øÌl HL¢V

®lJu¡S l¢qu¡­R ®pC Ae¤k¡u£ clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ algR¡e£fr a¡q¡C L¢lu¡­Re Hhw

HC p¤­k¡N­L pWa¡l p­‰ L¡­S m¡N¡­e¡l SeÉ jSql AflfrNZ Aœ j¡jm¡

c¡­ul L¢lu¡­Rez ¢a¢e B­l¡ ¢e­hce L­le ®k, Aœ j¡jm¡¢V C¢af§­hÑ Aœ

Bc¡ma qC­a e¡¢mn£ S¢j­a alfR¡e£ fr ®L¡e Eæue j§mL L¡S L¢lu¡­Re

¢Le¡ ®pC ¢ho­u ea¥e Cp¤É NWe f§hÑL f§­hÑl N¢Wa 6¢V Cpɤl p­‰ HL­œ

¢eØf¢šl SeÉ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡m­a ¢lj ¡­ä ®fËlZ Ll¡ qCu¡¢Rm Hhw ®pC Ae¤k¡u£ ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma ea¥e Cp¤É NWe f§hÑL ¢h­noax ANËœ²u j¡jm¡¢V J­ui¡l

Hhw HÉ¡L¥C­S¾p e£¢a­ah¡¢la j­jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ ®j¡a¡­hL ANËœ²u j¡jm¡¢V e¡-j”¤l

L­lez

AeÉ¢c­L 1-3 ew Aflf­r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h¡h¤ ®N±aj L¥j¡l l¡u

l¦­ml ¢h­l¡d£a¡ L¢lu¡ ¢e­hce L­le ®k, ¢h‘ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma Aflfr

jSql­cl ANËœ²­ul j¡jm¡¢V J­ui¡l HÉ¡L¥C­S¾p e£¢a­a h¡¢la pq Bw¢nL ANËœ²­ul c¡h£ AQm ¢hd¡u ANËœ²u j¡jm¡¢V e¡-j”¤l L­lez

AeÉ¢c­L ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma ¢ejÀ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡m­al l¡u J B­cn­L ¢li¡lp¡m j§­m Bf£m¢V j”¤l L¢lu¡­Rez ¢a¢e B­l¡ ¢e­hce L­le ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bf£m Bc¡ma ¢hØa¡¢la B­m¡Qe¡u ¢eSü A¢ij­al ¢i¢š­a ®k l¡u fËc¡e L¢lu¡­R a¡q¡ p¢WL Hhw abÉ pð¢maz ¢a¢e a¡qy¡l Efl

¢eiÑl L­le Hhw l²m¢V M¡¢l­Sl ¢e­hce L­lez

Bjl¡ Eiu f­rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£­cl hJ²hÉ nËhZ L¢lm¡j Hhw ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡ma Hhw ¢ejÀ Bf£m Bc¡m­al l¡u pj§qpq AeÉ¡eÉ e¢bfœ ¢hQ¡l ¢h­nÔoZ L¢lm¡jz e¢bcª­ø Cq¡ ü£L«a ®k, jSql -Bf£mL¡l£-

Aflfr Hhw ¢h­œ²a¡ HLC hw­nl ®m¡L Hhw ü£L«aj­a ®S¡­al pq nl£LJ h­Vz Bj¡l¡ fËb­j ®c¢Mh jSql -Aflfr NZ e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š M¢lc L¢l­a Afl¡Na¡ fËL¡n L¢lu¡¢R­me ¢L¡ Hhw k¡q¡l g­m a¡q¡­cl ANËœ²­ul A¢dL¡l J­ui¡l Hhw HÉ¡L¥C­S¾p e£¢a­a h¡¢la ¢Le¡ Hhw

algR¡e£-clM¡ØaL¡l£fr a¡q¡ fËj¡Z L¢l­a prj qCu¡­Re ¢Le¡?

¢hou¢V fËj¡­Zl SeÉ Bjl¡ phÑ fËbj algR¡e£ clM¡Ù¹L¡l£f­rl

¢m¢Ma A¡f¢šl fË¢a cª¢ø fÐc¡e L¢lhz clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ algR¡e£fr a¡q¡­cl ¢m¢Ma A¡f¢šl 5ew Ae¤­µR­c p¤ØfÖY~¡i­h E­õM L¢lu¡­Re ®k, jSql- Aflf­r l ANËœË ²­ul clM¡Ù¹¢V "Waiver and Acquiescence and

Estopple of Waiver à¡l¡ h¡¢la h­Vz" a¡q¡­cl ¢m¢Ma Bf¢šl fËL«a hªš¡­¿¹ B­l¡ E­õM L­le ®k, Òag¢pm i¨¢jl j¡¢mL cMmL¡l b¡­Le n¡¢¿¹ma¡

Ll J h¡cm Llz EJ² n¡¢¿¹ma¡ Ll Nw ag¢pm i¥¢j pq 1.19 na¡wn i¨¢j ¢hœ²u Ll¡l SeÉ jSql ­L Ae¤­l¡d L­lez jSql ag¢pm i¨¢j M¢lc L¢lh¡l ®L¡e pwN¢a e¡ b¡L¡l Lb¡ S¡e¡Cu¡ 1-3 ew alfR¡¢e­cl ¢eLV ¢hœ²u L¢lu¡

¢c­he h¢mu¡ Eš² n¡¢¿¹ma¡ Ll Nw ­L A¡nÄ¡p fÐc¡e L­lez Aaxfl jSql ­cl

h¡s£­a h¢pu¡ algR¡¢e­cl X¡¢Lu¡ ag¢pm i¨¢j M¢lc L¢lh¡l SeÉ Ae¤­l¡d L­lez 1-3 ew algR¡e£NZ jSql­cl M¢lc L¢lh¡l SeÉ Ae¤­l¡d L¢l­m jSql NZ a¡qy¡­cl Afl¡Na¡l Lb¡ fËL¡n L­lez Aaxfl jSql®cl jdÉÙ¹a¡u Hhw a¡q¡­cl p¢œ²u i§¢jL¡u HC algR¡e£NZ ag¢pm i¥¢jpq

1.19 HLl i¨¢j M¢lc L¢l­a l¡¢S qez jSql­cl Ef¢Öq¢a Hhw a¡q­cl Ae¤j¢a H²­j ®N¡f¡mf¤l NË¡­jl öile jäm ¢fw e¾c m¡m jäm, d£­l¾cÊe¡b jäm  ¢fw fnË¡¿¹L¥j¡l jäm, Q¡fl¡Cm  NË¡­jl n¡¢¿¹l”e f¡VJu¡l£ ¢fw jªa L¡¢nðl f¡­V¡u¡l£, j¢qoX¡¾c¡ (QœL¡¾c) NË¡­jl ®~n­m¾cÐe¡b ¢hnÄ¡p Jl­g ®hf¡l£ ¢fw nË£L¡¿¹ ¢hnÅ¡p Jl­g ®hf¡l£Nw­cl ®j¡L¡­hm¡ HC algR¡e£NZ 22/7/1997 a¡¢l­M ­L¡V¡m£f¡s¡ Hp,Bl , A¢g­p 2493 ew Lhm¡ c¢mm j§­m M¢lc Eq¡l cMm h¤¢Tu¡ f¡Cu¡ ag¢pm c¡­Nl j­dÉ h¡s£l c¡­N 1ew algR¡e£ Na Cw 27/7/1997 a¡¢l­M HLM¡e¡ ®c¡Q¡m¡ ¢V­el Ol Q¡fl¡C­ml ¢j¢Ù» ¢hf¤m ¢hnÄ¡p ¢fw d£­l¾cÐe¡b ¢hnÄ¡pJ lec¡ ¢hnÄ¡p, ¢fw lh£¾cÐe¡b ¢hnÄ¡p ®k¡N¡¢mu¡ ¢qp¡­h Eš² Ol E­š¡me L­lez EJ² Ol h¡hc 5,500/-V¡L¡ MlQ qCu¡­R Hhw hph¡­pl Ef­k¡N£ L¢lh¡l SeÉ ag¢pm h¡s£l c¡­N Na ®p­ÃVðl j¡­p 2200/- V¡L¡l j¡¢V 1ew algR¡e£ X~­š¡me L¢lu¡­Rz ®pM¡­e f¢lh¡l f¢lSe ¢eu¡ hph¡p L¢lu¡ B¢p­a­Rz"

algR¡e£-­lØfe­X¾V-clM¡ÙL¹¡l£­cl Eš² ¢m¢Ma Bf¢šl ü-f­r        1ew algR¡¢e ®kje p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L¢lu¡­Re ®aj¢e Eš² ®Le¡ ®hQ¡l pju Ef¢ÙÛa öile jäm 2ew J,¢f,X¢hÔE ¢qp¡­h Sh¡eh¢¾c­a h­me ®k,Òj¡jm¡l S¢jl c¡a¡ n¡¢¿¹ma¡ ®M¡s¡a ®h¡e, h¡cm i ¡N£e¡, S¢j ®Le¡-

®hQ¡l Lb¡ qJu¡l pju B¢j q¡¢Sl ¢Rm¡jz ¤L¥¾c Ll­L (1ew jSql) S¢j M¢lc L¢l­a h¢m­m V¡L¡ e¡ b¡L¡u M¢lc L­l e¡CzÓ J,¢f,X¢hÔE-3,

l­jn Ll Sh¡eh¢¾c­a h­me ""B¢j j¡jm¡l frNZ ­L ¢Q¢ez j¤L¾cLl (1ew jSql hw­nl ­m¡L) ®N±l¡®‰l (1ew algR¡e£) M¢lc¡ S¢j h¡c­ml ¢Rmz h¡cm HC S¢j j¤L¾cl (1ew algR¡e£) L¡­R ¢hœ²u L¢l­a Q¡uz f­l ®N±l¡­‰l L¡­R ¢h¢œ² L­lzÓ clM¡Ù¹L¡l£- algR¡e£l ¢m¢Ma Bf¢šl p­‰

p¡r £­cl ®j±¢ML p¡®r Él p¡j”pÉ l¢qu¡­Rz AeÉ ¢c­L Aœ ANËœ²u j¡jm¡ ¢h­œ²a¡­cl fr e¡ Ll¡u jSql clM¡Ù¹L¡l£­cl c¤hÑma¡ A¡­l¡ fÐØf¤¢Va qu

®k, ¢h­œ²a¡NZ jSql Aflf­r­cl e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j M¢lc Ll¡l SeÉ Ae¤­l¡d L¢lu¡¢R­me Hhw a¡q¡­cl jdÉÙÛa¡u clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ alfR¡e£l ¢eLV e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š ¢hœ²u qCu¡­Rz HC ¢hou¢V A¡­l¡ f¢lRæ kMe wc,Wvwe­D-1, †Rivq

e‡jb †h, we‡µZv‡ i evox cvkvcvwk Zv‡ i mv‡_ m¤úK© fv‡jv wQj|

ÔÔevox wewµ Kwiqv fviZ hvqÕÕ| wc, Wvwe­D-2, †Rivq e‡jb †h,

we‡µZvMY fviZ P‡j hvIqvi ci Rvwb, 8/10 w b ci Rvwb c‡i ‡Kn

Av‡m bvB we‡µZv‡ i bvwjkx Rwg‡Z Ni wQjÕÕ| jSql Aflf­r ab¡,

¢f,X¡¢hÔE-1 Hhw 2 Hl ®Sl¡u p¤Öføi¡­h fТauj¡e ®k, ¢h­œ²a¡­cl p­‰

a¡q¡­cl pÇfLÑ i¡­m¡ ¢Rm Hhw pq nl£L ¢qp¡­h a¡q¡C ü¡i¡¢hL ®p

®r­œ e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j ¢h¢œ²l pÇf­LÑ a¡q¡­cl e¡ S¡e¡‡bvl ¢hou¢V wek¦vm‡hvM¨

bq, Av‡iv †hLv‡b bvwjkx f~wgi wKQy Ask hLb evox †kªYxi| G †¶‡Î

wm×vš— MÖn‡Yi fVi¨¢j m„wó nq †h, gRni-Acic¶ cieZ©x‡Z wPš—v fvebv

Kwiqv jvfev‡bi D‡Ï‡k¨ AÎ AMÖµq gvgjv L¢lu¡­Re Zvnv cÖ_‡g

cwiZ¨vM Kwiqv wQ‡jb hvnvi d‡jI gvgjv vwLj Kwi‡Z wej¤¦ nBqv‡Q

Ges GB wej‡¤¦i KviY I h_v_©fv‡e eY©bv bv Kwiqv †KŠk‡j Gwoqv wMqv‡Qb| e¡¢b cª­ø A¡­l¡ mre£u ®k, 1 J 2 ew clM¡Ù¹L¡l£-alg R¡e£àu

fСb¢jL ¢hcÉ¡m­ul ¢nrL ­p ®r­œ a¡q¡­cl ANËœ²u pÇf­LÑ fСb¢jL

a¡lZ¡ b¡L¡l Lb¡, ®pC ¢qp¡­h pq kl£L­cl A‘­a üÒf A¡­ul

¢nrL®cl f­r Ha hs T¥¢L ­eJu¡ ¢hnÄ¡p­k¡NÉ e­q h¢mu¡ Ae¤­juz k¡q¡

qC­a d¡lZ¡ Ll¡ k¡u ®k, e¡¢mn£ ag¢p­ml pÇf¢š ¢h¢œ²l f§­hÑ jSql

Aflfr­cl Be¤ù ¡¢eLi¡­h S¡e¡­e¡ qCu¡¢Rm Hhw jSqlNZ B¢bÑL

Ap‰¢a b¡L¡u e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š M¢lc L¢l­a Afl¡Na¡ fËL¡n f§hÑL a¡q¡­cl

jdÉÙÛa¡u e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š algR¡e£-clM¡Ù¹L¡l£­cl hl¡­l ¢h¢œ² quz

A¢dL¿º e¢b cª­ø Av‡iv fËa£uj¡e ®k, e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š HL¢V ¢i¢V h¡s£pq

e£Q¤ S¢j ­kM¡­e 1ew algR¡e£ M¢l­cl HL pç¡­ql j­dÉ ab¡

27/07/1997 ¢MËx a¡¢l®M e¡¢mn£ agp£­ml h¡s£l pÇf¢š­a ®i¡N

cMmf§hÑL B­l¡ h¡s£-Ol E­š¡me L¢lu¡ hph¡p L¢l®a­Re, †hLv‡b 1bs ZicQvbx I wc,Wvwe­D-1, Revbew› ‡Z e‡jb ÔÔ wj‡ji Abygvb 5 w b ci 27/7/1997 Ni evoxÕÕGes †Rivq e‡jb 7 dzwUi 14 Lvbv wUb, evk Kv‡Vi LywU w qv Ni Kwi| wecyj I ev j Ni K‡i † u Hhw Eš² h¡s£l f¡­nC jSql -AflfrNZ hph¡p L­le Hhw 1 J 2 ew ¢f,X¡¢hÔE ab¡ jSqlàu J ®Sl¡u ü£L¡l L­le ®k, ¢h­œ²a¡l¡ h¡s£ ¢h¢œ² L¢lu¡ i¡l­a

k¡u a¡q¡l¡ 8/10 ¢ce fl S¡­eez H ®r­œ ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, jSql fr ANËœ²­ul ¢e¢j­š Aœ j¡jm¡ c¡­ul L¢lu¡­Re 13/04/1998 ¢MËx a¡¢l­M,

Bl c¢mm pÇf¡ce qCu¡­R 22/7/1997 ¢MËx a¡¢l­M ab¡ ANËœ²­ul ®j¡LŸj¡¢V c¡­ul qCu¡­R c¢mm pÇf¡c­el BV j¡p HL¥n ¢ce flz clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ Eš² M¢l­cl HL pç¡­ql j­dÉ ab¡ 27/07/1997 ¢MËx a¡¢l­M e¡¢mn£ h¡s£­a ¢V­el Ol °a¢l f§hÑL j¡¢V L¡¢Vu¡ hph¡p L¢l­a b¡­Le,

k¡q¡ jSqlN­Zl ®Q¡­Ml pÇj¤­M O¢Vu¡­R Hhw J,¢f,X¡¢hÔE 2,3,4,5, pL­mC p¡rÉà¡l¡ fÐj¡Z L¢lu¡­Re ®k, 1ew algR¡¢e e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š M¢l­cl flfl C e¡¢mn£ h¡s£­a hph¡p L¢l­a­Rez ®pM¡­e jSql- Aflf­rl e¡¢mn£ Lhm¡i Lb¡ flØfl S¡¢e­a cvwiqv avfl 10/3/1998 a¡¢l­M pC jql£ eLm a¥¢mu¡ Aœ j¡jm¡ c¡­ul Hl L¡le ¢hnÄ¡p ®k¡NÉ e­qz ®Lee¡ jSql Aflfr e¡¢mn£ Lhm¡ Rvbvi p¤¢e¢cÑø ®L¡e w b re gvgjv D™¢e‡ei L¡lZ E­õM L­le e¡Cz †Kb GZ † ix nBj

Ges ci¯úi ewj‡Z mywbw`©ó †Kvb e¨w³i bvg I D‡j­M K‡ib bvB hvnv †KŠkjMZfv‡e Gwoqv wMqv‡Qb ewjqv wek¦vm‡hvM¨| H ­r­œ ®cM¡ k¡u 1

J 2ew ¢f,X¢hÔE e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š ¢hœ²­ul ¢ho­u AhNa ¢R­me h¢mu¡ Ae¤j¡e ®k¡NÉz ¢h­œ²a¡NZ ¢hœ²­ul 8/10¢ce  fl i¡l­ Z k¡e a¡q¡J

ü£L«a, ®kM¡­e e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š ¢hœ²u qu 22/7/1997 ¢MËx a¡¢l­M ®pM¡­e

k¢c jSql-clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ ¢e­Sl¡C ü£L¡l L­le ¢h­œ²a¡l¡ S¡¢j ¢h¢œ² L¢lu¡ i¡l­a k¡e Hhw i¡l­a k¡Ju¡l 8/10¢ce fl a¡q¡l¡ S¡­e a¡­h a¡q¡­cl

S¡e¡l ab¡ 22/7/1997 wLªt ZvwiL+ 10¢ce fl nB‡Z 120¢c­el g‡a¨

j¡jm¡ Ll¡ E¢Qa ¢Rm ¢L¿º jSql- clM¡Ù¹L¡l£NZ j¡jm¡ c¡­ul L­le

13/4/1998 ¢MËx a¡¢l­M ab¡ c¢mm pÇf¡c­el 8(A¡V)j¡p, 21(HL¥n) ¢ce

Hhw jSql-Aflfr­cl ü£L«a Rvbv j­a 8 j¡p 11¢ce flz k¡q¡ qC­a p¤Øføi¡­h fТauj¡e ®k, j¡jm¡¢V a¡j¡¢c A¡C­e p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡­h h¡¢laz

¢h­œ²a¡NZ S¢j ¢h¢H² L¢lu¡ i¡l­a k¡e, k¡q¡ jSqlNZ La«ÑL

ü£L«a ®k­qa¥ jSqlNZ Hhw ¢h­œ²a¡NZ HLC hwn£u ab¡ pÇf­LÑl ¢c­L

j§m jSqlàu J ¢h­œ²a¡ h¡cmLl Q¡Q¡ i¡¢aS¡ Hhw ¢h­œ²a¡ n¡¢¿¹m¡aLl h¡cmL­ll j¡ Hhw jSqlà­ul ï¡œ£ hd§z H­r­œ ¢h‘ A¡CeS£h£l EܪaL«a ¢pÜ¡¿¹ …¢m Aœ ­j¡LŸj¡ ¢eÖf¢š­a pq¡uL i¨¢jL¡ l¡­M Hhw

®Sl¡u ®k­qa¥ jSqlNZ ü£L¡l L­le ®k,a¡q¡­cl p­‰ ¢h­œ²a¡­cl i¡m m¤úK© ®p­qa¥ e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š ¢h¢œ² pq h¡s£ R¡¢su¡ Q¢mu¡ k¡Ju¡l Lb¡

ph¡Ñ­NË S¡e¡l Lb¡ Hhw a¡q¡­cl ¢iV¡u AeÉ ®m¡L hph¡p Ll¡l L¡lZ

M¤y¢S­a ®cl£ qJu¡ p¢aÉC A¢hnÄ¡pÉ OVe¡ h¢mu¡ Bj¡­cl ¢eLV fËa£uj¡ez e¢b cª¢ÖV­a B­l¡ mre£u ®k, jSql -Afl frNZ pq nl£L qJu¡ p­aÄJ

e¡¢mn£ Lhm¡l Bw¢nL ANËœ²­ul clM¡Øa L¢lu¡­Rez jSql -Aflf­rl

ANËœ²­ul j§m ¢i¢š qC­a­R pq nl£L ¢qp¡­h HLC ­S¡­al j¡¢mL ¢qp¡­h

c¡h£c¡l ¢L¿¹ ®p­r­œ pq nl£L ¢qp¡­h Bw¢nL ANËœ²­ul c¡h£ BCeax

ANË¡qÉ, †Kbbv gRni-Acic¶MY 1.19 GKi m¤úwËi j­dÉ 1.12 HLl

pÇf¢šl AMÖµ‡qi iLv¯— Kwiqv‡Qb| H­r­œ 34¢X,Hm,Bl,(H¢X) 217,

q¡S£ BSjm Bm£l jªaɤ­a a¡q¡l Ju¡¢ln L¡jl²e ®eR¡ Nw -he¡j- Bë¤p

p¡š¡l Nw j¡jm¡u Bf£m ¢hi¡N LaѪL Nª¢qa ¢pÜ¡¿¹ HM¡­e e¢Sl ¢qp¡­h fË¢ed¡Z­k¡NÉ ®kM¡­e ¢pÜ¡¿ ¹qu ®k,  "Partial pre-emption not

allowed a co-sharer Tenant claims pre-emption–

contiguous land holder may pre-empt only that part

which is contiguous to his land"

 A¢dL¿¹ e¢b cª­ÖV B­l¡ ®cM¡ k¡u e¡¢mn£ i¨¢jl ¢h­œ²a¡­cl Aœ

ANËœ²u  j¡jm¡u  fr  Ll¡  qu  e¡Cz  k¢cJ  ¢h­œ²a¡  ANËœ²u  j¡jm¡u

AhnÉL£u  fr  e­qz  a­h  H­r­œ  a¡q¡­cl  fr  e¡  Ll¡u  jSql -

Aflfr­cl ‡Kvb wKQ~ Avovj Kivi ¢hou¢V ØfÖV qCu¡ E­W Hhw Cq¡ CµR¡L«a h¢mu¡ fË¢auj¡e quz ®p ®r­œ Aœ j¡jm¡ fr­c¡­o h¡¢la e¡

qC­m Aœ ANËœ²u j¡jm¡u Qlj A¢euj h¢mu¡ f¢lN¢ea Hhw a¡q¡­cl fr

e¡ L¢lu¡ jSql-Aflfr MY f­l¡ri¡­h ü£L ¡l L¢l­a­Re ‡k, ¢h­œ²a¡l¡

a¡q¡­cl ‘¡ap¡­l Hhw a¡q¡­cl jdÉÙ¹a¡u e¡¢mn£ i¨¢j ¢hœ²u L¢lu¡

i¡l­a Q¢mu¡ ¢Nu¡­Rez hvnv 1 J 2 bs ¢f,X¢hÔE a¡q¡­cl p¡­rÉJ ü£L¡l L¢lu¡­Rez ¢h­œ²a¡àu k¢c HC j¡jm¡u fr b¡¢L­ae Hhw q¡¢Sl qC­ae

a¡q¡ qC­m jSql-A¡f£mL¡l£-AflfrNZ ®k e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢šl ¢h¢œ²l

jdÉÙÛa¡u ¢R­me Hhw a¡q¡­cl ‘¡ap¡­lC e¡¢mn£ pÇf¢š ¢h¢œ² qCu¡­R

a¡q¡ fÐL¡n f¡Ca ¢hd¡u a¡q¡­cl HC j¡jm¡ fr Ll¡ qu e¡C h¢mu¡ Ae¤j¡e Ll¡l k¤¢š²¢eiÑl L¡lZ ¢hÉj¡e z HC ®r­œ p¡rÉ A¡C­el 114 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡ehm£ Ae¤plZ ®k¡NÉz

p¡¢hÑL fkÑ¡­m¡Qe¡ J ¢hQ¡l ¢h­nÔo­e fËa£uj¡e ®k jSql- A¡f£mL¡l£-Aflfr mn kixK nBqv bvwjkx wj‡ji m¤ú~Y© f~wgi AMÖµq vh£ K‡ib bvB weavq (1)Bw¢nL ANœ ˲q e£¢a­a h¡¢la, (2) gRni- A¡f£mL¡l£-Acic¶MY bvwjkx Rwg wewµi welq RvwbZ Ges Zvnv‡ i

ga¨¯’Zvq Zvnv iLv¯—Kvix Lwi K‡ib hvnv mv¶¨ Øviv fÐj¡¢Za Hhw

p¡rÉ A¡C­el 114 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e j­a Ae¤j¡e ®k¡NÉ ZvB J­ui¡l J

HÉ¡L¥C­S¾p J HÉ¡®ÖV¡fm e£¢a­a h¡¢la Hhw (3) gRni-A¡f£mL¡l£-

Acic¶‡ i mv¶¨ ­Sl¡u cÖgvwYZ †h, Zvniv bvwjkx f~wg wewµi 8/10

w b ci Rv‡bb wKš‘ gvgjv K‡ib 8 gvm 11 w b ci Zvnvl †Kvb

p­¿¹¡oSeL e¨vL¨v bvB weavq a¡j¡¢c BC­e h¡¢la h¢mu¡ Bj¡­cl

A¢ijaz ¢h‘ Bf£m Bc¡ma-B¢SÑ-Sh¡h, ®j±¢ML J c¡¢m¢mL p¡rÉ Hhw ¢ejÀ Bc¡m­al l¡u pq Eiu f­rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£­cl k¤¢J²aLÑ nËhZ f§hÑL ¢hQ¡l ¢h­nÔoZ f§hÑL j§mÉ¡ue L¢l­a hÉ¡bÑa¡l f¢lQu ¢cu¡ ï¡¿¹ d¡le¡u f¢aa qCu¡ a¢LÑa l¡u J B­cn fËc¡e L¢lu¡­Re k¡q¡ lre£u qC­a f¡­l

e¡ ¢hd¡u qØa­rf ®k¡NÉz

Hja¡hÙÛ¡u l¦­m p¡hÑš¡(Merit)  ¢hcÉj¡e  B­R  ¢hd¡u l¦m¢V Q¨s¡¿¹ qJu¡ E¢Qa h¢mu¡ Bj¡­cl A¢ijaz

 AaHh,

      gm¡gm,

       Ef­l¡J² L¡lZ J fkÑ¡­m¡Qe¡l Hhw ¢pÜ¡¿¹ …¢ml B­m¡­L l¦m¢V ¢he¡ MlQ¡u Q¨s¡¿¹ (Absolute)Ll¡ qCmz

 ¢ejÀ Bf£m Bc¡m­al ¢jp 9/2006 ew Bf£­m fËQ¡¢la 20/06/2007 ¢MËx a¡¢l­Ml l¡u J B­cn lc J l¢qa j­jÑ ¢hQ¡¢lL Bc¡m­al ¢jp 13/1998 ew j¡jm¡ fËQ¡¢la 20/04/2006¢MËx a¡¢l­Ml l¡u J B­cn hq¡m l¡M¡ qCmz

    l¡­ul L¢fpq ¢ejÀ Bc¡m­al e¢b A¢apaÄl ®gla f¡W¡e

qX~Lz

¢hQ¡lf¢a nl£g E¢Ÿe Q¡Lm¡c¡l x

B¢j HLja

H,¢h,J